Difference between revisions of "Overcoming Silos in Urban Regeneration Projects: Holistic Neighbourhood Design"

From Urban Arena Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(4 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:


[[File:Augustenborg picture.jpg |500px]]
[[File:Augustenborg picture.jpg |500px]]


'''Imagine a city consisting of ecologically sustainable urban neighbourhoods that are inclusive for its residents and resilient against climate change.'''
'''Imagine a city consisting of ecologically sustainable urban neighbourhoods that are inclusive for its residents and resilient against climate change.'''
Line 7: Line 8:
'''How can we create these neighbourhoods?'''  
'''How can we create these neighbourhoods?'''  


Creating truly sustainable, holistic neighbourhoods is often hindered by compartmentalized administrations and specialized, inconsistent policies. ‘Breaking down silos’ could mean, for example, that different departments of a municipality work together and with different local stakeholders for comprehensive sustainability projects and taking a variety of issues (e.g biodiversity, health, inclusivity, climate) into consideration at once. Additional change is needed in how specific topics are addressed: reducing the energy consumption in a neighbourhood might not just call for the technical improvement of buildings, but may also involve dedicated campaigns for changing energy related behaviour of residents.  
Creating truly sustainable, holistic neighbourhoods is often hindered by compartmentalized administrations and specialized, inconsistent policies. ‘Breaking down silos’ could mean, for example, that different departments of a municipality work together and with different local stakeholders for comprehensive sustainability projects and taking a variety of issues (e.g biodiversity, health, inclusivity, climate) into consideration at once [[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg#12. Who else is (going to be) involved in the intervention, and what was/is their main role?|(Q12)]]. Additional change is needed in how specific topics are addressed: reducing the energy consumption in a neighbourhood might not just call for the technical improvement of buildings, but may also involve dedicated campaigns for changing energy related behaviour of residents [[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg|(Q2)]].  


'''What are some key aspects for this to work? '''
'''What are some key aspects for this to work? '''


When pushing sustainable district and neighbourhood developments in your own city, being truly enthusiastic about the projects can be hugely important to get others on board. Individuals can play a very important role here. An area that has a bad reputation, where there is an already an urge for something to be done might be a good area to start a sustainable neighbourhood campaign. This can apply to neighbourhoods with diverse issues, such as high rates of unemployment, low involvement in politics, or even something really specific like susceptibility to flooding. A typical story of such a sustainable neighbourhood campaign could start with the municipality as an initiator. If this is supposed to be an integrated effort, however, the municipality would have to involve different local stakeholders, e.g the municipal housing company, local schools, and most importantly local residents.
When pushing sustainable district and neighbourhood developments in your own city, being truly enthusiastic about the projects can be hugely important to get others on board. Individual project champions can play a very important role here [[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg#13. Which particular interactions among various stakeholders (stakeholder configurations) were crucial in enabling the intervention to emerge successfully? This could include direct or indirect impacts on interventions.|(Q13)]]. An area that has a bad reputation, where there is an already an urge for something to be done might be a good area to start a sustainable neighbourhood campaign [[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg#13. Which particular interactions among various stakeholders (stakeholder configurations) were crucial in enabling the intervention to emerge successfully? This could include direct or indirect impacts on interventions.|(Q13)]]. This can apply to neighbourhoods with diverse issues, such as high rates of unemployment, low involvement in politics, or even something as specific as susceptibility to flooding [[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg#17. What circumstances or events are reported to have triggered the intervention? (In what ways?)|(Q17 & Q25)]]. A typical story of such a sustainable neighbourhood campaign could start with the municipality as an initiator [[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg#10. Who initiated the intervention?|(Q10)]]. If this is to be an integrated effort, however, the municipality would have to involve different local stakeholders, e.g the municipal housing company, local schools, and most importantly local residents [[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg#12. Who else is (going to be) involved in the intervention, and what was/is their main role?|(Q12)]].


'''And then, everything is fine?'''
'''And then, everything is fine?'''


Developments that try to tackle issues in single sectors (like, mobility or energy) will most likely take a long time to be implemented and could lead to a decline in public interest over the course of the project. Shifting responsibilities and making residents more responsible over the duration of the project might help with such issues. If projects aim to address different justice related issues, especially procedural justice, it would be crucial to carefully design participation processes. Such projects should engage residents and incorporate their needs and wishes.  
Developments that try to tackle issues in single sectors (like, mobility or energy) will most likely take a long time to be implemented and could lead to a decline in public interest over the course of the project [[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg#24. What has been done by each central actor group to overcome which particular obstacles in the way of successfully implementing the intervention? (this may include institutional Work - maintaining, disrupting, and creating new rules, applying to both formal laws/regulations and informal norms and expectations.)|(Q24)]]. Shifting responsibilities and making residents more responsible over the duration of the project might help with such issues [[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg#25. What are reported outcomes of the intervention? This may include economic outcomes, political outcomes, ability to reach sustainability and justice targets, etc.|(Q25)]]. If projects aim to address different justice related issues, especially procedural justice, it would be crucial to carefully design participation processes. Such projects should engage residents and incorporate their needs and wishes [[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg#24. What has been done by each central actor group to overcome which particular obstacles in the way of successfully implementing the intervention? (this may include institutional Work - maintaining, disrupting, and creating new rules, applying to both formal laws/regulations and informal norms and expectations.)|(Q24 & Q25)]].  


'''Where do we go from here?'''
'''Where do we go from here?'''


A sustainable neighbourhood will only exist if residents feel they are integral parts of it. Trying to push best practices onto the neighbourhood will most likely not work if residents do not understand why these developments are necessary or if they are opposed to proposed ideas. Still, organizing workshops that convey experiences from other areas might spark ideas for your own neighbourhood. As a municipality, taking up a perspective that provides guidance in what could be done to improve situations might sometimes be more feasible than telling residents what has to be done. Embracing such an open perspective as well as overcoming compartmentalized policies might be key in creating sustainable and resilient neighbourhoods.
A sustainable neighbourhood will only exist if residents feel they are integral parts of it. Trying to push best practices onto the neighbourhood will most likely not work if residents do not understand why these developments are necessary or if they are opposed to proposed ideas [[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg#31. Suggestions regarding transferability.|(Q31)]]. Still, organizing workshops that convey experiences from other areas might spark ideas for your own neighbourhood [[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg#26. According to the TRANSIT project’s four mechanisms for empowerment – i. funding; ii. legitimacy; iii. knowledge sharing, learning, and peer support; or iv. visibility and identity – please briefly describe the following, and indicate where the intervention has been developed or supported as part of which formal collaborations, networks or projects:|(Q26)]]. As a municipality, taking up a perspective that provides guidance in what could be done to improve situations might sometimes be more feasible than telling residents what has to be done [[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg#34. Has the intervention influenced higher-level governance arrangements such that sustainability and justice are considered (together) in a more durable, structural way? In other words, are there any observations about more structural, long-term changes as a result of the intervention?|(Q34)]]. Embracing such an open perspective as well as overcoming compartmentalized policies might be key in creating sustainable and resilient neighbourhoods.


'''How could this reality be created in your city? What obstacles would have to be overcome?'''
'''How could this reality be created in your city? What obstacles would have to be overcome?'''
Line 26: Line 27:


Take a look at the detailed description of [[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg]] that has inspired this scenario.
Take a look at the detailed description of [[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg]] that has inspired this scenario.
This project focuses on the work of Ekostaden Augustenborg, a holistic neighbourhood development programme based in the Augustenborg district in Malmö, Sweden including various social, ecological, and economical regeneration plans for the area.
This project focuses on the work of Ekostaden Augustenborg, a holistic neighbourhood development programme including various social, ecological, and economical interventions in the Augustenborg district in Malmö, Sweden.


This scenario relates to some '''enabling governance arrangements''':
This scenario relates to some '''enabling governance arrangements''':

Latest revision as of 18:15, 18 February 2021

This scenario has been developed on the basis of a real world case.

Augustenborg picture.jpg


Imagine a city consisting of ecologically sustainable urban neighbourhoods that are inclusive for its residents and resilient against climate change.

How can we create these neighbourhoods?

Creating truly sustainable, holistic neighbourhoods is often hindered by compartmentalized administrations and specialized, inconsistent policies. ‘Breaking down silos’ could mean, for example, that different departments of a municipality work together and with different local stakeholders for comprehensive sustainability projects and taking a variety of issues (e.g biodiversity, health, inclusivity, climate) into consideration at once (Q12). Additional change is needed in how specific topics are addressed: reducing the energy consumption in a neighbourhood might not just call for the technical improvement of buildings, but may also involve dedicated campaigns for changing energy related behaviour of residents (Q2).

What are some key aspects for this to work?

When pushing sustainable district and neighbourhood developments in your own city, being truly enthusiastic about the projects can be hugely important to get others on board. Individual project champions can play a very important role here (Q13). An area that has a bad reputation, where there is an already an urge for something to be done might be a good area to start a sustainable neighbourhood campaign (Q13). This can apply to neighbourhoods with diverse issues, such as high rates of unemployment, low involvement in politics, or even something as specific as susceptibility to flooding (Q17 & Q25). A typical story of such a sustainable neighbourhood campaign could start with the municipality as an initiator (Q10). If this is to be an integrated effort, however, the municipality would have to involve different local stakeholders, e.g the municipal housing company, local schools, and most importantly local residents (Q12).

And then, everything is fine?

Developments that try to tackle issues in single sectors (like, mobility or energy) will most likely take a long time to be implemented and could lead to a decline in public interest over the course of the project (Q24). Shifting responsibilities and making residents more responsible over the duration of the project might help with such issues (Q25). If projects aim to address different justice related issues, especially procedural justice, it would be crucial to carefully design participation processes. Such projects should engage residents and incorporate their needs and wishes (Q24 & Q25).

Where do we go from here?

A sustainable neighbourhood will only exist if residents feel they are integral parts of it. Trying to push best practices onto the neighbourhood will most likely not work if residents do not understand why these developments are necessary or if they are opposed to proposed ideas (Q31). Still, organizing workshops that convey experiences from other areas might spark ideas for your own neighbourhood (Q26). As a municipality, taking up a perspective that provides guidance in what could be done to improve situations might sometimes be more feasible than telling residents what has to be done (Q34). Embracing such an open perspective as well as overcoming compartmentalized policies might be key in creating sustainable and resilient neighbourhoods.

How could this reality be created in your city? What obstacles would have to be overcome?

Do you want to learn more about this scenario?

Take a look at the detailed description of Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg that has inspired this scenario. This project focuses on the work of Ekostaden Augustenborg, a holistic neighbourhood development programme including various social, ecological, and economical interventions in the Augustenborg district in Malmö, Sweden.

This scenario relates to some enabling governance arrangements:

This scenario fits under the approaches:

It addresses some drivers of injustice:

What do you think about this scenario? Was it helpful to you? Do you find our approach problematic? Send us an email to Philipp Spaeth.