Difference between revisions of "Database of governance arrangements"

From Urban Arena Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(48 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
In many places across Europe, people experiment with local governance arrangements that are favorable to justice and sustainability. Based on real word experiments (mostly within EU-funded projects), we developed 11 '''rich descriptions''' that capture the crucial variables enabling this intervention to successfully emerge. Covering a large variety of sectors i.e. mobility, energy, food or housing as well as governance modes i.e. government-led, hybrid or citizen-led, these 11 rich descriptions inform about sustainable and just governance arrangements. They have furthermore been translated into '''11 brief governance scenarios''' that aim to be inspirational.  
Across Europe there is an inspiring array of experimentation with local governance arrangements for just and sustainable cities.  


== Governance arrangements, sorted according to their contribution to governance ambitions ==
What is '''governance'''? It can be broadly understood as all formal and informal political processes (involving state and non-state actors) that lead to collective action.


The broad topic of urban governance arrangements for sustainability and justice can be disaggregated into more specific ambitions. Often discussed are the following:
On this database, you will find the summaries of results of a study on fruitful governance interventions for sustainable and just cities.  


[[A) Policy Integration]]
Would you like to get involved? We've asked some questions in the following sections, and you can share your suggestions with us via email to [[User:Philipp Spaeth|Philipp Spaeth]]. If you haven't already, please feel free to join the [[UrbanA Community of Practice]].


[[B) Bridging Institutional Logics]]
<span style="color: red;"> '''DISCLAIMER: This page is currently under review! While the rich descriptions and governance scenarios remain the same, we are shifting our approach away from governance ambitions towards what we call governance arrangements. More detail to follow shortly.'''</span>


[[C) Engaging Inhabitants]]
== Enabling governance arrangements ==


[[D) Alternative Metrics]]
Enabling governance arrangements are elements that we identified as being important for supporting initiatives for just and sustainable cities. Looking at a selection of eleven situated governance interventions for sustainable and just cities (as summarized in our scenarios), we asked: “What key elements of governance arrangements enabled those interventions to come to fruition?”


We have discussed how these ambitions are tentatively realized in promising experiments at a [https://urban-arena.eu/event/urbana-community-conversation-governance-tools/ Community Conversation] on '''June 23rd, 2020'''. Documentation of the event is available on the [https://medium.com/urban-arenas-for-sustainable-and-just-cities/how-governance-arrangements-foster-both-urban-sustainability-and-justice-be7ab3786b46 UrbanA blog].
We assume that the enabling governance arrangements that we identified as important in these cases (building on project reports and interviews), can be important for other cases too. However, we do not claim that these enabling arrangements are the sole factors for bringing interventions to fruition, as the latter will always be embedded in local contexts with place-based factors being important as well.  


When clicking on one of the ambitions A) - D) above, you will find a list of the scenarios and detailed descriptions of governance interventions related to these governance ambitions.  
In order to provide inspiration or even guidance in other contexts, enabling governance arrangements cannot be defined overly specific or overly broad: they are concrete, fluid and adaptive, transferable; tailored, and generally relevant.  


Which further ambitions do you consider crucial on the way towards governance for sustainability AND justice in cities?
When clicking on one of the enabling governance arrangement A) - D) below, you will learn about the ambition this each enabling governance arrangement as well as about the scenarios and detailed descriptions of governance experiments it relates.
And what other examples do you know where these ambitions have been guiding the setting up of arrangements for justice oriented sustainability governance?


Please share your suggestions with us, e.g. via email to  [[User:Philipp Spaeth|Philipp Spaeth]].
[[A) Embracing flexibility in project management]]
Please also contribue to the development of further case studies and governance scenarios on this wiki and join the [[UrbanA Community of Practice]].


== Governance arrangements, sorted according to governance modes ==
[[B) Creating a comprehensive vision of change]]


Some governance arrangements for sustainability and justice in cities are initiated by local governments, while others are initiated by social movements or even enterprises. We present here some scenarios and governance interventions that are driven primarily by governmental actors, civil society or hybrid arrangements: 
[[C) Institutionalising intermediaries]]


[[A) Government led]]
[[D) Committing to a meaningful participation process]]


[[B) Civil society driven]]
[[E) Tapping into resources of existing community networks and learning]]


[[C) Hybrid arrangements]]
[[F) Develop resilient, and self-sufficient business models]]  


When clicking on one of the modes A) - C) above, you will find a list of the scenarios and detailed descriptions of governance interventions that are best illustrating these governance modes.
Which further enabling governance arrangement do you consider crucial on the way towards governance for sustainability AND justice in cities?


And what other examples do you know where these ambitions have been guiding the setting up of arrangements for justice oriented sustainability governance?
== Governance interventions ==


Please share your suggestions with us, e.g. via email to  [[User:Philipp Spaeth|Philipp Spaeth]].


== Governance arrangements, sorted according to sectors ==
We have selected eleven real-word experiments (mostly within EU-funded projects) and developed '''detailed descriptions''' which detail their governance variables and processes. We have also created a brief '''governance scenario''' per case studied. These scenarios share general insights in a narrative style, and we hope that they pique your interest and provide inspiration about what could be possible in your city!


Governance arrangements for sustainability and justice in cities differ from sector to sector due to the specific nature of services provided in these sectors.  
We stress that the interventions presented below (the detailed descriptions and the corresponding scenarios) - '''are not exemplary “successful interventions”'''. Rather, they are regarded as '''general inspiration''' and real-world cases for testing out how to enable translocal learning.
We describe in detail some governance arrangements that have been developed in the following sectors:


[[A) Mobility]]
{| class="wikitable"
|- style="font-weight:bold; text-align:center; background-color:#efefef;"
! Detailed governance intervention descriptions
! Brief governance scenarios
|-
| 1.[[Bottom-up resistance against gentrification in Rome]]
| 1.[[Learning from successful community-based actions against gentrification]]
|-
| 2.[[Citizens rescuing and sharing food in Berlin]]
| 2.[[Expanding effective practices for food rescuing and sharing among cities]]
|-
| 3.[[Community led affordable housing in Brussels]]
| 3.[[A new take on affordable housing through community owned and developed dwellings]]
|-
| 4.[[Dealing flexibly with and learning from resistance in Barcelona]]
| 4.[[Inviting citizens to a transformation of street space - flexibly dealing with resistance]]
|-
| 5.[[Biodiversity protection and social justice in the Barcelona Natural Park]]
| 5.[[Balancing long term sustainability and short-term social needs in peri-urban green space]]
|-
| 6.[[Co-creation of a sustainable neighborhood in Freiburg]]
| 6.[[Envisioning and co-creating sustainable urban neighborhoods by reaching across institutional boundaries]]
|-
| 7.[[Public-private partnerships for sustainability infrastructure in Athens]]
| 7.[[Bringing sustainable infrastructure to all - carefully engaging in public-private partnerships]]
|-
| 8.[[Inner-city community energy in London]]
| 8.[[From electricity to empowerment, community energy growing out of the inner-city]]
|-
| 9.[[Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg]]
| 9.[[Overcoming compartmentalization in urban regeneration projects for inclusive sustainability and resilience]]
|-
| 10.[[Citizens share in Berlin Energy Grid for sustainable energy]]
| 10.[[Making local energy systems inclusively sustainable - by ourselves, with a little help by friends]]
|-
| 11.[[Regeneration of a deprived neighborhood in Rotterdam]]
| 11.[[Trusting civil society and residents to co-shape regeneration projects in deprived neighborhoods]]
|}


[[B) Housing]]
Template for developing further descriptions: [[Rich description template]]


[[C) Food]]
== Methodology ==


[[D) Energy]]
''(Coming soon)''
 
[[E) Urban development/regeneration]]
 
[[F) Biodiversity protection]]
 
When clicking on one of the sectors A) - F) above, you will find a list of scenarios and detailed descriptions of governance interventions developed mainly within this sector.
 
And what other examples of justice oriented sustainability governance in these sectors do you know?
 
Please share your suggestions with us, e.g. via email to [[User:Philipp Spaeth|Philipp Spaeth]].
 
== Full list of brief governance scenarios ==
 
# [[Learning from successful community-based actions against gentrification]]
# [[Expanding effective practices for food rescuing and sharing among cities]]
# [[A new take on affordable housing through community owned and developed dwellings]]
# [[Inviting citizens to a transformation of street space - flexibly dealing  with resistance]]
# [[Balancing long term sustainability and short-term social needs in peri-urban green space]]
# [[Envisioning and co-creating sustainable urban neighborhoods by reaching across institutional boundaries]]
# [[Bringing sustainable infrastructure to all - carefully engaging in public-private partnerships]]
# [[From electricity to empowerment, community energy growing out of the inner-city]]
# [[Overcoming compartmentalization in urban regeneration projects for inclusive sustainability and resilience]]
# [[Making local energy systems inclusively sustainable - by ourselves, with a little help by friends]]
# [[Trusting civil society and residents to co-shape regeneration projects in deprived neighborhoods]]
 
== Full list of detailed governance interventions ==
 
# [[Anti-gentrification resistances case]]
# [[Foodsharing case]]
# [[Community Land Trust case]]
# [[Barcelona Superblocks case]]
# [[Peri-Urban Collserola Natural Park case]]
# [[Vauban neighborhood case]]
# [[Stravos Niarchos Fundation Cultural Center Case]]
# [[Brixton Energy case]]
# [[Augustenborg]]
# [[Burger Energie Berlin case]]
# [[Resilience Lab case]]
 
== Template for developing further descriptions ==
 
*[[Rich description template]]

Revision as of 15:39, 8 October 2020

Across Europe there is an inspiring array of experimentation with local governance arrangements for just and sustainable cities.

What is governance? It can be broadly understood as all formal and informal political processes (involving state and non-state actors) that lead to collective action.

On this database, you will find the summaries of results of a study on fruitful governance interventions for sustainable and just cities.

Would you like to get involved? We've asked some questions in the following sections, and you can share your suggestions with us via email to Philipp Spaeth. If you haven't already, please feel free to join the UrbanA Community of Practice.

DISCLAIMER: This page is currently under review! While the rich descriptions and governance scenarios remain the same, we are shifting our approach away from governance ambitions towards what we call governance arrangements. More detail to follow shortly.

Enabling governance arrangements

Enabling governance arrangements are elements that we identified as being important for supporting initiatives for just and sustainable cities. Looking at a selection of eleven situated governance interventions for sustainable and just cities (as summarized in our scenarios), we asked: “What key elements of governance arrangements enabled those interventions to come to fruition?”

We assume that the enabling governance arrangements that we identified as important in these cases (building on project reports and interviews), can be important for other cases too. However, we do not claim that these enabling arrangements are the sole factors for bringing interventions to fruition, as the latter will always be embedded in local contexts with place-based factors being important as well.

In order to provide inspiration or even guidance in other contexts, enabling governance arrangements cannot be defined overly specific or overly broad: they are concrete, fluid and adaptive, transferable; tailored, and generally relevant.

When clicking on one of the enabling governance arrangement A) - D) below, you will learn about the ambition this each enabling governance arrangement as well as about the scenarios and detailed descriptions of governance experiments it relates.

A) Embracing flexibility in project management

B) Creating a comprehensive vision of change

C) Institutionalising intermediaries

D) Committing to a meaningful participation process

E) Tapping into resources of existing community networks and learning

F) Develop resilient, and self-sufficient business models

Which further enabling governance arrangement do you consider crucial on the way towards governance for sustainability AND justice in cities?

Governance interventions

We have selected eleven real-word experiments (mostly within EU-funded projects) and developed detailed descriptions which detail their governance variables and processes. We have also created a brief governance scenario per case studied. These scenarios share general insights in a narrative style, and we hope that they pique your interest and provide inspiration about what could be possible in your city!

We stress that the interventions presented below (the detailed descriptions and the corresponding scenarios) - are not exemplary “successful interventions”. Rather, they are regarded as general inspiration and real-world cases for testing out how to enable translocal learning.

Detailed governance intervention descriptions Brief governance scenarios
1.Bottom-up resistance against gentrification in Rome 1.Learning from successful community-based actions against gentrification
2.Citizens rescuing and sharing food in Berlin 2.Expanding effective practices for food rescuing and sharing among cities
3.Community led affordable housing in Brussels 3.A new take on affordable housing through community owned and developed dwellings
4.Dealing flexibly with and learning from resistance in Barcelona 4.Inviting citizens to a transformation of street space - flexibly dealing with resistance
5.Biodiversity protection and social justice in the Barcelona Natural Park 5.Balancing long term sustainability and short-term social needs in peri-urban green space
6.Co-creation of a sustainable neighborhood in Freiburg 6.Envisioning and co-creating sustainable urban neighborhoods by reaching across institutional boundaries
7.Public-private partnerships for sustainability infrastructure in Athens 7.Bringing sustainable infrastructure to all - carefully engaging in public-private partnerships
8.Inner-city community energy in London 8.From electricity to empowerment, community energy growing out of the inner-city
9.Holistic neighbourhood development Augustenborg 9.Overcoming compartmentalization in urban regeneration projects for inclusive sustainability and resilience
10.Citizens share in Berlin Energy Grid for sustainable energy 10.Making local energy systems inclusively sustainable - by ourselves, with a little help by friends
11.Regeneration of a deprived neighborhood in Rotterdam 11.Trusting civil society and residents to co-shape regeneration projects in deprived neighborhoods

Template for developing further descriptions: Rich description template

Methodology

(Coming soon)